Loading... Please wait...

Which players have performed the best in the postseason?

Posted by

October 06, 2009

Performing well during the regular season is one thing, but producing in October wins championships. As we await the Twins-Tigers playoff and the Division Series, let's take a look at the best playoff performers among active players.

Most Productive Hitters by On-Base Plus Slugging
(minimum 50 Plate Appearances)
Player Games Plate
Appearances
Home Runs Avg
OPS
Carlos Beltran 22 101 11 .366 1.302
Troy Glaus 19 82 9 .347 1.246
Jason Bay 11 51 3 .341 1.105
Kevin Youkilis 26 113 6 .333 1.023
Albert Pujols 53 226 13 .323 1.022
Lance Berkman 29 129 6 .321 .992
B.J. Upton 16 72 7 .288 .985
Jayson Werth 20 83 4 .292 .983
Carlos Guillen 19 69 2 .344 .978
Nomar Garciaparra 32 127 7 .321 .975

Astros fans will remember Carlos Beltran's torrid 2004, and Rays fans won't forget B.J. Upton’s 2008. Albert Pujols is right in line with his regular season production as the best hitter in the game. Alex Gonzalez and Adam Everett have fared the worst in the postseason, each posting an On-base Plus Slugging below .500. For those interested, Alex Rodriguez ranks 28th of 104 qualifying players, Derek Jeter places 31st, and David Ortiz comes in 12th.

Because Earned Run Average is volatile, particularly in small samples, we rank pitchers based on Component Earned Run Average, which uses pitchers' hits, walks, and home runs allowed to measure their effectiveness:
Most Productive Pitchers by Component Earned Run Average
(minimum 15 Innings Pitched)
Player Games Innings
Pitched
Strikeouts ERA
Component
ERA
Jonathan Papelbon 16 25.0 22 0.00 0.64
Mariano Rivera 76 117.3 93 0.77 1.13
Hideki Okajima 16 21.0 16 2.14 1.55
Alan Embree 31 21.7 13 1.66 1.64
Cole Hamels 6 41.7 37 2.16 1.65
Jon Garland 2 16.0 11 2.25 2.00
Brad Lidge 26 34.3 51 2.10 2.05
Chad Bradford 24 23.3 13 0.39 2.05
Jason Isringhausen 23 26.7 23 2.36 2.10
Carl Pavano 8 19.3 15 1.40 2.13

The top two names on this list should surprise no one, but Hideki Okajima has been nearly as successful. Alan Embree, owner of a career 4.59 regular-season Earned Run Average, has been stellar across seven postseasons (and five different teams). A broken leg will keep him on the Rockies' bench this October.

Full postseason stats are available in the 2010 Bill James Handbook, available November 1.


Sign up to our newsletter

Recent Updates