Posted by John Dewan on Dec 16th 2015
March 27, 2013
For the most part, Spring Training statistics provide little predictive value. Many players use that time to play into shape and to work on specific aspects of their game, such as developing a specific pitch. Often, players face less than major-league quality opponents. On top of that, the sample sizes are so small in Spring Training that, even if teams played them as they do the regular season, it would be difficult to predict performance levels for the rest of the season.
However, we have found one element of spring training performance that has some predictive value: power spikes. Players that show a 200-point increase in their slugging percentage over their career levels have performed significantly above their career marks in the upcoming season 60 percent of the time. Jose Bautista in spring of 2010 is the most famous recent example. Last season, the predictions nailed the breakout performances among catchers in Carlos Ruiz, Jonathan Lucroy, and A.J. Pierzynski. Cody Ross, Billy Butler, and Tyler Colvin also enjoyed career years.
Here’s the list of 2013 breakout candidates (with a minimum of 200 regular season at-bats and 40 spring training at-bats through March 26, 2013):
Slugging Percentages of Top Breakout Candidates | |||
Hitter, Team | Spring | Career | Difference |
Brandon Belt, Giants | .906 | .418 | .488 |
Justin Smoak, Mariners | .811 | .377 | .434 |
Howard Kendrick, Angels | .833 | .428 | .405 |
Ryan Raburn, Indians | .833 | .430 | .403 |
Nick Hundley, Padres | .773 | .390 | .383 |
Rick Ankiel, Astros | .780 | .422 | .358 |
Michael Morse, Mariners | .824 | .492 | .332 |
Mike Moustakas, Royals | .726 | .395 | .331 |
Brent Lillibridge, Cubs | .675 | .350 | .325 |
Mark DeRosa, Blue Jays | .725 | .412 | .313 |
Lonnie Chisenhall, Indians | .725 | .421 | .304 |
Kevin Youkilis, Yankees | .778 | .482 | .296 |
Domonic Brown, Phillies | .675 | .388 | .287 |
Mitch Moreland, Rangers | .727 | .441 | .286 |
Wilin Rosario, Rockies | .805 | .522 | .283 |
Dexter Fowler, Rockies | .705 | .427 | .278 |
Alex Gordon, Royals | .714 | .439 | .275 |
Craig Gentry, Rangers | .618 | .355 | .263 |
Gaby Sanchez, Pirates | .683 | .420 | .263 |
Bryce Harper, Nationals | .730 | .477 | .253 |
Juan Francisco, Braves | .692 | .440 | .252 |
Elvis Andrus, Rangers | .604 | .353 | .251 |
Brandon Crawford, Giants | .577 | .333 | .244 |
Steve Clevenger, Cubs | .523 | .281 | .242 |
Melky Cabrera, Blue Jays | .655 | .414 | .241 |
Lucas Duda, Mets | .660 | .427 | .233 |
Raul Ibanez, Mariners | .700 | .470 | .230 |
Luis Cruz, Dodgers | .600 | .371 | .229 |
Gerardo Parra, Diamondbacks | .625 | .400 | .225 |
Freddie Freeman, Braves | .671 | .449 | .222 |
Peter Bourjos, Angels | .614 | .402 | .212 |
Ben Francisco, Yankees | .636 | .425 | .211 |
Aaron Hill, Diamondbacks | .636 | .432 | .204 |
Lorenzo Cain, Royals | .615 | .412 | .203 |